The Measure ULA Citizen Oversight Committee voted Thursday to advance a package of developer tax breaks on newly constructed housing, despite growing evidence undermining the case for those concessions. The committee determined that the proposal would further the purposes of the voter-approved tax and approved it without changes, even as members questioned the research and political campaign behind the push for exemptions. The seven members voting approved the framework unanimously, sending it to City Council for further consideration.
The incentives are meant to address claims that Measure ULA, the voter-approved transfer tax that has raised more than $1.4 billion since 2023 for affordable housing, homelessness prevention, and tenant protections, is discouraging housing construction. But researchers have challenged studies blaming ULA for slowing development, while recent data show increases in multifamily property transactions, building permits, and housing starts.
The framework approved by the committee is far narrower than the sweeping exemptions originally proposed by Councilmember Nithya Raman. Her proposal would have exempted newly constructed or substantially renovated apartment buildings, commercial properties, and mixed-use developments from Measure ULA for 15 years. The compromise instead proposes a five-year pilot program offering reduced ULA tax rates or full exemptions on the first qualifying sale of newly constructed residential properties within 10 years of receiving a certificate of occupancy. The size of the tax break would depend on the affordable housing, labor protections, and anti-displacement benefits developers provide. Projects meeting the highest requirements could avoid the tax entirely.
The United to House LA (UHLA) coalition supports the compromise, which emerged from a months-long City Council process involving multiple proposals that would have significantly reduced revenue for ULA-funded programs. Unlike earlier proposals, the new incentive program is narrowly targeted at newly constructed housing and does not extend tax breaks to commercial or industrial developers, previously completed developments, or substantial renovations of existing properties. With LAHD anticipating only a modest impact on ULA revenue, the coalition supports this more thoughtful approach, which ties incentives to affordable housing, labor standards, and anti-displacement protections.
But the coalition’s support for this narrower compromise does not settle the underlying question of whether developers need tax breaks at all. As several members of the Citizens Oversight Committee pointed out, the evidence that ULA is discouraging housing construction remains deeply contested. Indeed, the growing body of research suggests that even these more limited concessions may be unnecessary.
The Push to Weaken ULA
The compromise is the latest chapter in a fight that started almost immediately after Los Angeles voters approved Measure ULA with 57.8% of the vote in November 2022. Since the tax took effect in April 2023, real estate interests have repeatedly blamed it for slowing property sales and discouraging construction. Elected officials have followed developers’ lead, pursuing proposals to exempt newly constructed housing.
But the evidence behind those claims has come under increasing scrutiny. As Mar Vista Voice previously reported, a widely cited UCLA Lewis Center study became central to the campaign to weaken ULA despite serious questions about its methodology and conclusions. A September 2025 critique by researchers affiliated with UCLA, USC, and Occidental College challenged the study’s approach, including its treatment of broader economic conditions.
In April 2026, researchers Greg Bonett and Madeline Wander reexamined the UCLA study’s data and code and found that its authors had effectively confused a decline in average project size with a decline in the number of homes being permitted. Their analysis found no meaningful monthly decline in permitted housing units in the study sample, undermining a central finding used to argue that ULA was suppressing construction.
A separate analysis by BAE Urban Economics looked at whether ULA actually made housing projects financially harder to build. It found that eliminating the tax generally made little difference to whether projects were viable. Developments that couldn’t pencil out with ULA were typically infeasible without it, while projects that were already viable generally didn’t need an exemption to move forward. The biggest effects were on developers looking to quickly flip newly constructed properties for a profit. But discouraging that kind of speculation isn’t a problem the city needs to solve by handing out tax breaks.
Recent market data also undercut the idea that ULA has brought housing development to a halt. As Mar Vista Voice reported in December 2025, residential construction permits increased 60% in the third quarter of 2025 compared with the previous year, while housing entitlements rose 52% between 2022 and 2024. Developers also submitted applications or pre-applications for more than 16,600 homes during the first six months of the city’s new housing incentive program. Residential permits then increased another 30% year over year in the fourth quarter of 2025.
None of these figures alone settles the debate over ULA’s effects. But taken together with the newer research, they raise serious questions about the case for weakening the tax. City officials have nevertheless continued proposing exemptions, leading to the compromise approved Thursday.
Oversight Committee Members Question the Case for Concessions
That tension was evident during the Citizens Oversight Committee’s discussion. While members ultimately supported the carefully designed pilot, several questioned the premise that ULA was harming housing production in the first place. Their concerns highlighted a central contradiction in the city’s approach: even as officials move forward with developer concessions, the evidence that those concessions are necessary remains remarkably thin.
Danielle Williams, who has a PhD and expertise in research methodology, said she would support the compromise and appreciated LAHD’s approach, but expressed concern that the proposal was responding to studies by UCLA and RAND that she said contained methodological problems, particularly in their use of difference-in-differences analysis, and overstated their findings.
Williams warned that the studies had been “weaponized by I think a very well funded PR machine that’s set on undermining ULA,” with their conclusions amplified by media outlets that lacked the expertise or interest to scrutinize them. She worried that the city’s response could encourage similar campaigns in the future, allowing flawed research to have an outsized influence on public policy.
“Again, this is not a reflection of the pilot,” Williams said. “I think the pilot is really well designed and I do think it furthers the ULA.”
Committee member Kristal Romero agreed with Williams’ concerns and raised similar questions about efforts to undermine labor standards. She emphasized the importance of preserving the labor protections included in the negotiated incentive program. Romero criticized the narrative that prevailing wages and project labor agreements were among the biggest obstacles to affordable housing construction, saying, “We’re not going to build affordable housing off the backs of workers.” She expressed hope that the pilot would provide evidence about whether the incentives actually lead to more construction.
The discussion also raised questions about whether ULA was responsible for slowing construction in the first place. Committee Chair Zerita Jones asked LAHD whether there was data showing a slowdown in housing production and, if so, whether it could be directly attributed to ULA.
LAHD’s Maya Abood acknowledged that city data showed fewer permits than in previous years, but said the decline was “highly correlated with changes to the interest rates.” She cautioned that “it is hard for us to disentangle what might be ULA and what is the broader macroeconomic environment,” adding that Los Angeles is difficult to compare with other jurisdictions because of the much greater scale of development in the city.
Rather than treating ULA’s impact on construction as established, Abood explained, the department had approached the pilot as an opportunity to encourage projects that provide affordable housing, stronger labor standards, and protections against displacement. “Maybe this helps, maybe it doesn’t, we’ll find out,” she said.
What Developers Would Get Under the New Program
Despite those concerns, the committee determined that the proposed incentives would further ULA’s purposes and voted to advance them without changes. The proposed program offers three tiers of tax breaks:
The first tier would reduce ULA’s current rates of 4% and 5.5% to 2% and 3% for qualifying transactions. Developers would generally have to reserve 8% of units for extremely low-income households, 11% for very low-income households, or 20% for low-income households, or meet another qualifying affordability standard. Protections against the loss of existing affordable housing would also apply.
The second tier would lower the rates further, to 1% and 1.5%, for projects meeting additional requirements, including prevailing wages and replacement of demolished protected housing. Certain majority-affordable developments in high-market areas could qualify through an alternative pathway.
The third tier would provide a full exemption from ULA for projects that reserve at least half their units for households earning up to 80% of area median income and meet additional labor and anti-displacement requirements. These include prevailing wages, replacing demolished protected units at a 10-to-1 ratio, restrictions on demolishing 12 or more recently occupied rent-stabilized units, and project labor agreements for buildings over 85 feet tall.
But what counts as “affordable” deserves a closer look. Under LA’s 2026 income limits, a single person earning as much as $93,300 a year, or a family of four earning $133,250, can qualify for housing designated for households earning up to 80% of area median income. By comparison, someone working full-time at the $18.42 minimum wage earns just $38,314 a year before taxes and can afford about $958 a month in rent and utilities without spending more than 30% of their income on housing. An apartment that meets the program’s affordability requirements could still be far beyond that worker’s reach.
Some of the proposed incentives require housing for people at much lower income levels. But under the highest tier, developers could qualify for a complete ULA exemption without reserving a single unit for extremely low-income residents. That’s a significant concession for a tax intended to address the city’s housing affordability crisis.
What Will the Tax Breaks Cost, and What Will They Deliver?
And these tax breaks come at the expense of the very programs ULA was created to fund. Every dollar developers save under the exemptions is a dollar that won’t go toward ULA-funded housing and tenant protections. On a $30 million property sale, the current 5.5% rate would generate $1.65 million for ULA. A developer qualifying for the third tier could pay no ULA tax at all, resulting in $1.65 million in foregone revenue. To receive that exemption, the developer would have to reserve at least half the units for households earning up to 80% of area median income and meet the other requirements, even though those affordable units could still be out of reach for many of the city’s lowest-income residents.
That money could otherwise help fund affordable housing development and preservation, eviction prevention, and programs that keep people in their homes. So the question isn’t simply whether developers are offering something in exchange for a tax break. It’s whether those benefits are worth diverting money from programs already serving people struggling with housing costs.
LAHD expects the overall revenue impact to be relatively small, particularly in the early years of the program. During the presentation, Abood said that only about 1% of historical ULA revenue came from transactions involving newer buildings sold within 10 years of receiving their certificates of occupancy. But she also acknowledged that future transaction patterns could differ from those observed in the past. And even if relatively few transactions qualify, individual developers could receive substantial tax savings. In one example presented by LAHD, a $250 million downtown development would save $10 million in ULA taxes under the second tier.
That relatively modest projected revenue impact is an important part of why UHLA supports the compromise. Compared with earlier proposals that would have extended exemptions across broad categories of commercial and residential property, the pilot substantially limits the number of transactions eligible for tax breaks while requiring developers to provide public benefits in return. But a smaller revenue loss does not necessarily mean the city is getting its money’s worth.
There’s also the question of whether the incentives will actually change what gets built. Developers could receive exemptions for projects they were already planning to build, leaving the city with less revenue and no additional housing to show for it. In other cases, a tax break might make a project financially viable or persuade developers to include more affordable units and stronger protections.
LAHD acknowledged that it does not have a quantified goal for how many additional affordable units or qualifying projects the pilot is expected to produce. The city needs to distinguish between those outcomes rather than counting every project receiving a tax break as a success. LAHD proposes evaluating the pilot based on its effects on housing construction, property transactions, and ULA-funded programs before deciding whether to continue, modify, or end it. The program would automatically expire after five years unless the Council determines, based on a study, that it should continue. That’s especially important given how much of the original case against ULA has been called into question.
The committee also approved a separate package of technical amendments to Measure ULA, addressing issues including nonprofit ownership structures, affordability covenants, and certain property transfers. That package passed with seven votes in favor and one abstention. The committee determined that both proposals would further ULA’s purposes and advanced them without amendments.
The incentive framework is not yet an ordinance. LAHD expects to bring it before the Council’s Housing Committee and the full Council in November and December, after which the City Attorney would prepare implementing legislation. The proposed ordinance would then return to the Citizens Oversight Committee in spring 2027 before going back to the Council for final adoption.
The Council will now decide whether to approve the incentives, and with them, a reduction in revenue voters specifically dedicated to affordable housing and tenant protections. The negotiated proposal is considerably more limited than the sweeping exemptions developers and elected officials initially sought, and its affordability, labor, and anti-displacement requirements offer meaningful protections. But the committee’s approval does not resolve the central question of whether even these concessions are necessary. With research challenging the claims used to justify developer exemptions, the burden should remain on proponents to demonstrate that the tax breaks will produce housing that otherwise would not be built, rather than simply rewarding projects that would have moved forward anyway.